Publikationen und Vorträge

@misc{lorenz2019nbsp,

title = {CC-Lizenzen: The good,  the maybe not so good, and the c&p licences},

author = {Anja Lorenz},

url = {https://kurzelinks.de/5minTermine-OER

https://chaotikum.org/blog/2019/05/17/5-min-termine5/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gglw8tg9160},

year  = {2019},

date = {2019-05-22},

urldate = {2019-05-22},

address = {Lübeck},

organization = {Chaotikum},

series = {5-Minuten-Termine},

abstract = {Nicht alle Creative-Commons-Lizenzen sind wirklich offen. Ich erkläre, warum OER mit ND- und NC-Lizenzen ihre Schwierigkeiten haben.},

howpublished = {Kurzvortrag},

keywords = {copyright, creative commons, leisure, lightning talk, open education, open educational ressources (OER)},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2019oer19,

title = {JOINTLY for OER: How should a public repository and service provider for OER look like?},

author = {Anja Lorenz and Annett Zobel and Markus Deimann and Philipp Wieder},

url = {https://oer19.oerconf.org/sessions/jointly-for-oer-how-should-a-public-repository-and-service-provider-for-oer-look-like-o-094/

http://bit.ly/oer19-jointly 

http://bit.ly/jointly18-en},

year  = {2019},

date = {2019-04-11},

urldate = {2019-04-08},

address = {Galway},

organization = {Association for Learning Technology (ALT)},

abstract = {Session Description

All over the world, a multitude of mostly grassroot initiatives have emerged to enable, promote and support the use of OER. Despite the heterogeneity and fragmentation of these different initiatives, the actors are united in their striving for a stronger implementation of OER in everyday education.



If we want the idea of OER to become widespread, it would be foolish if everyone had to develop all resources by themselves. Thus, it would be useful to join efforts and provide these resources and services to the OER community via an appropriate infrastructure.



For this purpose, we would like to briefly present our recent platforms, tools, and services developed for (but not limited to) the OER community in German-speaking countries. Afterwards, we are looking forward to a lively discussion on further experiences and ideas on the question, to what extent we can strengthen the rather decentralized OER topic by such joint(ly) approaches for the open education community, i.e. beyond the German-speaking community.



# Background

In 2016, the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research startet a funding program to spread the idea of OER by recruiting multipliers from diverse audiences. “JOINTLY” is one of these projects, led by edu-sharing network, Technische Hochschule Lübeck (University of Applied Sciences), GWDH and iRIGHTSinfo. The project supports multipliers in their cooperation. This takes place on the one hand through events for the sharing and expansion of knowledge and for the joint development of ideas, solutions and OER materials. On the other hand, through the joint design and testing of IT tools and infrastructures that facilitate practical cooperation and, last but not least, through information about the legal framework of OER, which is essential for sustainable cooperation.



So what are OER multipliers looking for? Since the end of 2016 we have been working on this question and have already come up with some first solutions:

The OER content buffet can be seen as the heart of JOINTLY: Concepts, summaries, material, templates and tools that can be reused for further OER transfer projects and modified for specific audiences.

The OER Tool Playground is a testing environment for tools that promote the creation, use and dissemination of OER. Mature results are offered via the OER content buffet.

Further information services include the series of booklets on the subject of legal issues relating OER production as well as guidelines for decision-makers.

In addition, JOINTLY has developed and refined cooperation events. In working groups, workshops, think tanks and hackethons, not only the OER content buffet and the OER tool playground were developed and improved with a larger community, but also smaller solutions such as the CC mixer were born there.



After the first phase of the project until September 2018, we were successful with a second project proposal. Until 2020 we will proceed with our work for the German OER community. One of our next goals is also to take even greater account of international developments in the context of OER and to network with these actors.



JOINTLY is funded by the Federal Ministry of Education and Research (funding ID: 01PO18011C).



# References

JOINTLY project (2018). Short Project Description in English [online]. Available at: https://jointly.info/en/ [Accessed 28.11.2018].

JOINTLY project (2018). OER-Contentbuffet [online]. Available at: https://oer-contentbuffet.info [Accessed 28.11.2018].

JOINTLY project (2018). OER-Playground [online]. Available at: https://playground.oer-contentbuffet.info/ [Accessed 28.11.2018].

JOINTLY project (2018). CC Mixer [online]. Available at: http://ccmixer.edu-sharing.org/ [Accessed 28.11.2018].},

howpublished = {10th annual conference for Open Education research, practice and policy (OER19), 10–11 April 2019, Galway, IRL},

keywords = {Germany, infrastructure, JOINTLY, learning material, open education, open educational ressources (OER), platforms, practices, tools, train the trainer},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2019subscribe,

title = {OER für N00bs: Podcasts als freie Bildungsressourcen},

author = {Anja Lorenz and Oliver Tacke},

url = {https://fahrplan.das-sendezentrum.de/subscribe10/talk/DLGG3R/},

year  = {2019},

date = {2019-03-23},

urldate = {2019-03-23},

address = {Köln},

abstract = {Nicht nur kostenlos, sondern offen: Mit offenen Lizenzen können Podcasts auch prima zum Lehren und Lernen eingesetzt werden.



Als Urheber*innen könnt Ihr selbst darüber entscheiden, wer Euren Podcast auf welche Art und Weise nutzen darf. Wenn Ihr dafür offene Lizenzen benutzt (vor allem die Creative-Commons-Lizenzen), legt Ihr klar fest, unter welchen Bedingungen euer Werk kostenfrei kopiert, verwendet und weiterbearbeitet werden kann. So können frei lizenzierte Podcasts als sog. Open Educational Ressources (OER) ohne komplizierte Nutzungsverträge zum Lernen und Arbeiten in und außerhalb von Bildungseinrichtungen eingesetzt werden.



Im Talk gehen wir kurz auf offene Lizenzen im Zusammenspiel mit OER ein und zeigen einige Beispiele aus der Podcast-Welt. Er soll Denkanstöße geben, ob eine freie Lizenz für euren Podcast infrage käme, aber auch wie Ihr mit offenen Materialien im Podcast und im Bildungsbereich arbeiten könntet.},

howpublished = {Vortrag auf der SUBSCRIBE 10: Konferenz & Workshop für Podcasting},

keywords = {bldgaltentf, edufunk, leisure, open educational ressources (OER), podcast},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2019subscribeb,

title = {Lernen mit Podcasts: Nicht-formale Formate zur Weiter-/Bildung},

author = {Anja Lorenz and Oliver Tacke and Tine Nowak and Christian Friedrich},

url = {https://fahrplan.das-sendezentrum.de/subscribe10/talk/GKVSDL/

https://hackmd.io/s/HyI0u1-u4},

year  = {2019},

date = {2019-03-23},

urldate = {2019-03-23},

address = {Köln},

abstract = {Podcasts können auf verschiedene Weise zum Lehren und Lernen benutzt werden. Wir diskutieren gemeinsam mit euch Potentiale und tauschen Erfahrungen aus.



Wer hat nicht schon Neues in einem Podcast gelernt? Wir (@anjalorenz, @friedelitis, @otacke und @tinowa) wollen diese Lern-Potentiale zusammen mit euch diskutieren und Erfahrungen dazu austauschen:



Wie und wer lernt mit Podcasts?

Wie kann ich meinen eigenen Podcast überarbeiten, damit andere damit besser lernen können?

Welche Lizenzen eignen sich besonders (Stichwort: Creative Commons & OER)?

Welche Formate gibt es bisher, die von Vornherein Lernen und Bildung als Ziel haben?

Und was könnte oder sollte es noch geben, was fehlt bisher?},

howpublished = {Vortrag auf der SUBSCRIBE 10: Konferenz & Workshop für Podcasting},

keywords = {bldgaltentf, edufunk, informal learning, leisure, open educational ressources (OER), podcast},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{Theis201835c3,

title = {Digital what? Wie man Bildung nicht digitalisieren sollte},

author = {Dominik Theis and Anja Lorenz and Jelisaweta Kamm},

url = {https://cfp.verschwoerhaus.de/35c3/talk/ZKJDBE/

http://bit.ly/bfb-35c3},

year  = {2018},

date = {2018-12-29},

urldate = {2018-12-29},

address = {Leipzig},

organization = {Bündnis Freie Bildung},

abstract = {Regierungen und politische Entscheidungstragende setzen auf die Forcierung und den Ausbau von Plattformen, um Bildung "endlich" zu digitalisieren. Doch die Umsetzung widerspricht dem Ziel, Menschen dazu zu befähigen, sich im digitalen Raum sicher und mündig zu bewegen.},

howpublished = {Vortrag auf dem 35. Chaos Communication Congress #35c3},

keywords = {Bündnis Freie Bildung, Cloud, learning management system (LMS), leisure, MILLA, politics, school, SchulCloud},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz18montagsbildung,

title = {Twitter Shadowban},

author = {Anja Lorenz},

url = {http://bit.ly/bchl18-shadowban},

year  = {2018},

date = {2018-12-17},

urldate = {2018-12-17},

address = {Lübeck},

school = {Technische Hochschule Lübeck},

howpublished = {Vortrag im Rahmen der Montagsbildung beim ILD},

keywords = {BarCamp Lübeck (#bchl), leisure, montagsbildung, shadowban, twitter},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2018oeb,

title = {Make MOOCs Count for Higher Education},

author = {Anja Lorenz and Heba Ledwon and Maria Blöcher},

url = {https://oeb.global/},

year  = {2018},

date = {2018-12-07},

urldate = {2018-10-09},

address = {Berlin},

abstract = {This Panel brings together three partners presenting different approaches to make the most out of MOOCs for Higher Education through examination and quality assurance measures. Learn about their common project INTEGRAL+ (Integration and Participation of Refugees in the Context of Digital Teaching and Learning Scenarios), funded by the German Federal Ministry for Education and Research and its methods and tools. You are invited to identify more good practices and innovative solutions - and to contribute to an exchange on the European credit system (ECTS) and opportunities to validate non-formal learning with experts in the field. },

howpublished = {Session auf der OEB Global 2018 "Shaping the Future of Learning"},

keywords = {higher education, integration, Kiron, massive open online course (MOOC), pMOOCs, refugees},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2018metanook,

title = {OER: Wie sieht das in Echt aus?},

author = {Anja Lorenz},

url = {http://bit.ly/metanook18-OER

https://youtu.be/gGYtr-Xdjmw

https://2018.nook-luebeck.de/2018/talk/lightning-talks-2},

year  = {2018},

date = {2018-11-09},

urldate = {2018-11-09},

address = {Lübeck},

abstract = {Eigentlich steckt hinter Open Educational Resources (OER) nicht mehr, als Lernmaterialien, die unter einer freien Lizenz veröffentlicht werden. Diese freien Lizenzen erlauben anderen Lernenden und Lehrenden, dass sie dieses Material weiterverbreiten, aber auch für ihre Zwecke anpassen dürfen. Damit man sich noch besser vorstellen kann, wie OER in der Praxis aussehen können, werden einige der Projekte vorgestellt, die sich um den OER-Award 2016 oder 2017 beworben hatten.},

howpublished = {Lightningtalk auf der MetaNOOK 2018},

keywords = {lightning talk, OER-Award, OERde, open educational ressources (OER)},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2018metanook2,

title = {Das BarCamp Lübeck},

author = {Anja Lorenz and Kai Obermüller},

url = {http://bit.ly/metanook18-bchl

https://metanook.de/2018/talk/lightning-talks-2},

year  = {2018},

date = {2018-11-09},

urldate = {2018-11-09},

address = {Lübeck},

abstract = {Das BarCamp Lübeck geht 2018 in die dritte Runde. Dennoch ist noch nicht allen das Format solchen „Unkonferenzen“ bekannt. Hier gibt es keine eingeladenen Vorträge, alle sind Expertinnen und Experten auf einem Bereich. Worum es geht? Das bestimmen die Teilnehmenden am Morgen eines jeden BarCamp-Tags.



Wir stellen in unserem Talk das BarCamp-Format generell vor und berichten aus unseren Erfahrungen „hinter den Kulissen“ der letzten 2,5 Jahre im Orga-Team.},

howpublished = {Lightningtalk auf der MetaNOOK 2018},

keywords = {BarCamp, BarCamp Lübeck (#bchl), leisure, lightning talk},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2018diwokiel,

title = {Open Educational Ressources (OER): Was ist das und wie sieht das aus?},

author = {Anja Lorenz},

url = {http://bit.ly/diwokiel-oer

https://digitalewochekiel.de/programm/rund-um-open-data/},

year  = {2018},

date = {2018-09-11},

urldate = {2018-09-06},

address = {Kiel},

howpublished = {Beitrag in der Session "Rund um Open Data" auf der Digitalen Woche Kiel 2018},

keywords = {OER-Award, open educational ressources (OER)},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2018opera,

title = {Ein eigenes OER als Prüfungsleistung: Ergebnisse aus dem Weiterbildungsprogramm der OER-Fachexperten},

author = {Anja Lorenz},

url = {http://bit.ly/oerulm-oerexp

https://www.uni-ulm.de/einrichtungen/saps/projekte/opera/netzwerkveranstaltung-2018/},

year  = {2018},

date = {2018-05-03},

urldate = {2018-04-11},

address = {Ulm},

school = {Universität Ulm},

abstract = {Nach zwei Workshops und zwei Online-Veranstaltungen nehmen einige Teilnehmerinnen und Teilnehmer nun noch die letzte Stufe in unserer Fortbildung zum/zur OER-Fachexpert*in: eine mündliche Prüfung zu einem selbst erstellten OER. Die Prüfungskommission besteht dabei immer aus mindestens einer Person aus unserem Projektteam sowie einem externen Prüfer, der bereits eine weitreichende Expertise im Themenfeld OER aufweisen kann.



So bekommen wir in diesen Tagen eine immense Vielfalt freier Lernmaterialien der Teilnehmenden zu Gesicht: Neben Arbeitsblättern und Checklisten sind auch Videos und ganze Online-Kurse entstanden. Einen guten Einblick dazu kann man im Forum der 2. Online-Phase erhalten, in denen die Teilnehmenden ihr OER und das dahinterliegende Konzept vorstellen.



Nach einer erfolgreich bestandenen Prüfung nehmen wir die frisch gebackenen OER-Fachexpertinnen und -Fachexperten in unsere „Hall of Fame“ auf, die sich in den nächsten Tagen sicher noch weiter füllen wird.},

howpublished = {Vortrag auf der Informations- und Netzwerktagung "University goes OER - Offene Bildungsmaterialien an Hochschulen und in der akademischen Weiterbildung" im Rahmen des Projekts OpERA},

keywords = {eAssessment, massive open online course (MOOC), mooin, OER-Fachexperten (OERexp), OERde, open educational ressources (OER)},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz18oegoexp,

title = {OER Maker and multipliers in continuing education},

author = {Markus Deimann and Anja Lorenz},

url = {http://bit.ly/oeglobal18oerexp



http://sched.co/Dpc8},

year  = {2018},

date = {2018-04-26},

urldate = {2018-03-22},

address = {Delft},

abstract = {For a long time, continuing education has been dominated by a regime of intellectual property. Most learning materials have been restrictively licenced as they were seen as the (social) capital for trainers, coaches and other adult educators. 



This situation led to a strong barrier for the adoption of Open Educational Resources (OER) in adult education contexts. Even though, OER offer immense potential for continuing education and even for self-employed trainers. Therefore, it is the main target of the project “OER Content-Expert” to explain basic principles and advantages of OER for this specific audience. 



Funded by the German Ministry of Education and Research, it is part of the program line to develop and implement trainings to sensitize multiplicators for OER in various educational settings. In particular, it is aimed at freelancer who have no or little prior knowledge about OER. Using a blended learning scenario, learners are introduced to the idea and possibilities of OER:

Kick-off: This is for a first introduction to OER in a 3h workshop taking place at one of 20 cities in Germany. 

First Online-Phase: A MOOC, lasting 8 weeks with a workload of approximately 3h/week.

Workshop: After learning the basics of OER, participants will work on an individual OER project at a workshop (2 days). 

Second Online-Phase: This is intended as a preparation for the examination and for the finalisation of the individual OER-project. 

Examination: A presentation of the individual OER-project is given in an online setting. An expert jury will provide feedback. The formal evaluation will, if the participant is successful, result in a certification. 



At the moment (October 2017), nearly 400 participants are enrolled in the MOOC and 61 have received a certificate.},

howpublished = {Beitrag auf der Open Education Global Conference (OER Global)},

keywords = {massive open online course (MOOC), mooin, OER-Fachexperten (OERexp), open educational ressources (OER)},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz18oeglobal2,

title = {External MOOCs on mooin: Experiences on opening up an institutional MOOC platform},

author = {Anja Lorenz},

url = {http://bit.ly/oeglobal18moocmaker



http://sched.co/Dpbv},

year  = {2018},

date = {2018-04-26},

urldate = {2018-03-22},

address = {Delft},

abstract = {The MOOC platform mooin is run by the University of Applied Sciences since 2015 to host self-produced MOOCs. In summer 2016, it was also opened up for external persons or institutions searching a platform to host their own MOOCs. What began with personal requests only has established in a fixed process, supported by an own “mooin Maker MOOC” as a tutorial for external MOOC makers. Until today and still in addition to self-produced MOOCs, more that 20 external MOOCs are published on mooin.



The presentation introduces the process from an exclusively self-used MOOC platform to one that is also open for third-party MOOC makers. In addition, the results of an online survey among the external MOOC makers tell more about their motivation and ressources, but also about their experiences with the MOOC platform mooin.},

howpublished = {Beitrag auf der Open Education Global Conference (OER Global)},

keywords = {massive open online course (MOOC), mooin},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz18oeglobal3,

title = {An Award for Open Educational Resources – an innovative approach to defining quality in OER},

author = {Anja Lorenz and Jöran Muuß-Merholz},

url = {http://joeran.de/oeglobalawards/



http://sched.co/DpZv},

year  = {2018},

date = {2018-04-24},

urldate = {2018-03-22},

address = {Delft},

abstract = {o promote the efforts of practioners in the field OER to a wider public, the German OER-Award has been granted for the first time as part of the OER-Festival in February 2016. Elected by a jury of OER experts, there was not only an OER-Award in several educational field, but also in special domains. The second OER-Awards will have been granted in November 2017 following the collaboratively-designed process to identify deserving nominees and winners.



The presentation describes the short history of the German OER-Awards including changes that has been made for the second edition. Next to best practices also the challenges will be discussed. Finally, we will welcome your feedback to improve the process for the 3rd edition of our OER-Awards.},

howpublished = {Beitrag auf der Open Education Global Conference (OER Global)},

keywords = {OER-Award, OERde, OERde16, OERde17, open educational ressources (OER)},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz18oeglobal4,

title = {Make MOOCs count for higher education: Approaches to awarding ECTS Credits for learning in open online courses},

author = {Sebastian Knoth and Anja Lorenz and Florian Rampelt},

url = {http://bit.ly/oeglobal18integral



http://sched.co/DpZc},

year  = {2018},

date = {2018-04-24},

urldate = {2018-03-22},

address = {Delft},

abstract = {MOOCs provided by Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) have the potential to open up education to a wider audience. By implementing appropriate quality assurance measures, they could also provide a first creditable step into the formal higher education system. Exploring the potential of credentialization and recognition of MOOCs was a major pillar of the INTEGRAL²-project (“Integration and Participation of Refugees in the Context of Digital Teaching and Learning Scenarios”) of Lübeck University of Applied Sciences, RWTH Aachen University and Kiron Open Higher Education. The partners explored possible combinations of the openness of MOOC-based learning with quality assurance and examination approaches that abide to standards of the European Higher Education Area. 



Regarding quality assurance measures, Kiron has repurposed and adapted tools developed through the Bologna Process in order to explore new pathways to the recognition of prior learning. A core element are MOOC booklets (MOOklets) that connect and display all quality information needed for recognition in a comparable, standardized way.



As the university partners identified the existing exams within MOOC’s to be the most critical part in order to award legitimate credit points, the partners followed two different approaches: Module-based competence assessment (on- and offline) and MOOC-based examinations (offline). Lübeck University of Applied Sciences tested a procedure to verify learning outcomes by written and oral examinations whilst RWTH Aachen University targeted a more traditional examination approach with written and e-exams that can be taken simultaneously at different offline locations. In the follow-up project INTEGRAL+, the partners will focus on establishing a German examination network for e-assessment of MOOC-based learning. 



Both efforts in the field of a firm examinations and the endorsement of recognition processes of all existing and future university partners within the Kiron network can lead to simplified admission process and can be key enablers of a successful integration via education.},

howpublished = {Beitrag auf der Open Education Global Conference (OER Global)},

keywords = {higher education, integration, Kiron, massive open online course (MOOC), mooin, refugees},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{mm2018oeglobal,

title = {10 years EduCamps, 6 years OERcamps: Transforming Education through Open Conference Formats},

author = {Jöran Muuß-Merholz and Blanche Fabri},

url = {http://joeran.de/oeglobalbarcamps/

http://sched.co/DpZl},

year  = {2018},

date = {2018-04-24},

urldate = {2018-05-07},

address = {Delft},

abstract = {Barcamps represent an unconference format with a common theme but without pre-planned programme. The session schedule is designed collaboratively at the beginning of each (un-)conference day. In Germany there are several barcamps in the field of education. Two of them will be highlighted from the position of members of their organising teams. “Educamps” on digital media in education started in 2008 and have since taken place 21 times. “OERcamps” on Open Educational Resources started in 2012 and have since taken place 9 times.



A recent review of OER-related activities in Germany on behalf of UNESCO (Orr, Neumann, Muuß-Merholz 2017, 8) found: “Since OER activities are mostly driven bottom-up, there has been a need for sharing questions, experiences and materials between players, who have been isolated in their own institutions. These players found opportunities for sharing in cross-sector events and communities. Especially the barcamp/unconference format turned out to fit tremendously well developing a strong German OER community. Indeed, Germany so far has seen a remarkably strong cross-sector community with common interest in OER.”



Barcamps open up new and contemporary formats for learning based on openness, sharing, personal meaning, participation and equality. They are the appropriate format of education for a time in which we are depending on not only transferring fixed knowledge but also co-creating new knowledge. Barcamps are about sharing, discussing, negotiating solutions for a world in change. Barcamps are one way of transforming education through open approaches from bottom-up.



Barcamps are not only a real best practice of open pedagogy and open educational practices. They are also the source of collective development and use of open educational materials. The documentation with collaboratively text documents, blogging, podcasts etc. are mostly shared under a CC BY licence. The organisers also provide templates for documentation and planning under CC BY.},

howpublished = {Beitrag auf der Open Education Global Conference (OER Global)},

keywords = {BarCamp, educamp, OERCamp, OERde, OERde16, OERde17, open educational ressources (OER)},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2018oer18,

title = {The OER Awards in Germany. Promoting #Open through awarding best practice},

author = {Jöran Muuß-Merholz and Anja Lorenz},

url = {http://joeran.de/oer18award/



https://oer18.oerconf.org/sessions/the-oer-awards-in-germany-promoting-open-through-awarding-best-practice-1909/},

year  = {2018},

date = {2018-04-19},

urldate = {2018-03-22},

address = {Bristol},

organization = {Association for Learning Technology (ALT)},

abstract = {The Ljubljana Action Plan 2017 puts a strong emphasis on “high quality” of OER (UNECO 2017), that is not a trivial issue when it comes to education (Ehlers 2009). The German “OER awards” aim at new ways of discussing and promoting OER.



Though Germany has been a latecomer to the OER scene, there is a strong OER community now (Orr, Neumann, Muuß-Merholz 2017). To promote the idea and the sharing of OER in German-speaking regions, there have been OER awards in early 2016 and in November 2017.



Overview

The OER awards highlight the efforts of OER practitioners in more than 10 categories. Furthermore, there was an audience award in 2016 that was linked to a funding for the best OER idea, that must be realized with the prize money, and special awards by the jury in 2016 and 2017 without submission options.



Criteria

A special focus was set on the elaboration of definitions for requirements and criteria. Contributions must be



- Open as described in the Open Definition (published by Open Knowledge International).

- Educational as in “designed for educational purposes”.

- Resource in the sense of “delimitable and transferable”. This explicitly includes software and concepts.

- German, i.e. in German language or (!) predominantly developed in a German language country.



In 2017 the following criteria were used for assessment:



- temporal relevance (must date from later than early 2016)

- participation and collaboration in the making

- didactic quality, innovative pedagogical settings

- licencing

- range, use, impact

- potential for actual reuse

- quality development and quality assurance

- technical quality

- X-factor (wild card for positive qualities not covered in the criteria mentioned above)



Quality of the content regarded from a subject perspective was NOT among the criteria.



It should be noted that these criteria were developed in an open and collaborative process among a jury of OER experts. All steps of the election processes were organized online as the jury never met before the ceremony. Supported by a moodle course and a set of Google Documents and Formulas, the process was adapted to the several steps and needs of the jury.



Outline of the Session

In our presentation we will give an overview on the idea and the process behind the OER award and show some statistics and figures. A special focus will be set on the community driven work within the “oer academy” in which the process, the criteria and the selection of awardees are discussed openly. Showcasing awarded projects will NOT be part of the presentation. We will instead focus on the question how an award can contribute to promoting the idea and the sharing of OER.



References

Ehlers, U. D. (2009). Understanding quality culture. Quality Assurance in Education, 17(4), 343-363.



Orr, D.; Neumann, J.; Muuß-Merholz, J. (2017). German OER Practices and Policy – from Bottom-up to Top-down Initiatives. http://iite.unesco.org/publications/3214746/



UNESCO (2017). “Ljubljana OER Action Plan 2017.” Adopted by the second World Open Educational Resources (OER) Congress in Ljubljana in September 2017. https://en.unesco.org/sites/default/files/ljubljana_oer_action_plan_2017.pdf},

howpublished = {9th annual conference for Open Education research, practice and policy (OER18), 18–19 April 2018, Bristol, UK},

keywords = {OER-Award, OERde, OERde16, OERde17, open educational ressources (OER)},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{mm2018oer18,

title = {Conferences open to all! Mainstreaming open education through unconferences and barcamps},

author = {Jöran Muuß-Merholz and Blanche Fabri},

url = {http://joeran.de/oer18oercamp/

https://oer18.oerconf.org/sessions/conferences-open-to-all-mainstreaming-open-education-through-unconferences-and-barcamps-1873/},

year  = {2018},

date = {2018-04-19},

urldate = {2018-05-07},

address = {Bristol},

organization = {Association for Learning Technology (ALT)},

abstract = {Barcamps or open conferences are open education events which are open to all. They represent an unconference format with a common theme but without pre-planned programme. The session schedule is designed collaboratively at the beginning of each (un-)conference day. In Germany there are several barcamps in the field of education. Three of them will be highlighted. “Educamps” on digital media in education started in 2008 and have since taken place 21 times. “OERcamps” on Open Educational Resources started in 2012 and have since taken place 9 times. “InklusionsCamp” on inclusive education which has taken place for the first time in 2015.



A recent review of OER-related activities in Germany on behalf of UNESCO (Orr, Neumann, Muuß-Merholz 2017, 8) found: “Since OER activities are mostly driven bottom-up, there has been a need for sharing questions, experiences and materials between players, who have been isolated in their own institutions. These players found opportunities for sharing in cross-sector events and communities. Especially the barcamp/unconference format turned out to fit tremendously well developing a strong German OER community. Indeed, Germany so far has seen a remarkably strong cross-sector community with common interest in OER.”



Barcamps open up new and contemporary formats for  learning based on openness, sharing, personal meaning, participation and equality. They are the appropriate format of education for a time in which we are depending on not only transferring fixed knowledge but also co-creating new knowledge. Barcamps are about sharing, discussing, negotiating solutions for a world in change. Barcamps are one way of transforming education through open approaches from bottom-up.



Barcamps are not only a real best practice of open pedagogy and open educational practices. They are also the source of collective development and use of open educational materials  (Bernhardt & Kirchner 2009). The documentation with collaborative text documents, blogging, podcasts etc. are mostly shared under a CC BY licence. The organisers also provide templates for documentation and planning under CC BY.



Barcamps provide a radical “Open to all” approach by lowering the barriers by removing participation fees and any formal requirements, fostering cross sectoral collaboration, encouraging volunteering and peer to peer support for participants, facilitate ways of participation via digital media. Barcamps aim to be truely inclusive events.



In this presentation we will give an overview on these characteristics. We would also like to encourage the participants to discuss how they can bring open conferencing to their home turfs.



References

Bernhardt, T., & Kirchner, M. (2009). Web 2.0 Meets Conference: The EduCamp as. Looking Toward the Future of Technology-Enhanced Education: Ubiquitous Learning and the Digital Native, 192.

Greenhill, K., & Wiebrands, C. (2008). The unconference: a new model for better professional communication.

Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity. Cambridge university press.

Orr, D., Neumann, J., & Muuß-Merholz, J. (2017). German OER Practices and Policy — from Bottom-up to Top-down Initiatives. UNESCO Institute for Information Technologies in Education (IITE).},

howpublished = {9th annual conference for Open Education research, practice and policy (OER18), 18–19 April 2018, Bristol, UK},

keywords = {BarCamp, educamp, OERCamp, OERde, OERde16, OERde17, open educational ressources (OER)},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2017bchl,

title = {Making},

author = {Anja Lorenz and Kai Obermüller},

url = {http://bit.ly/bchl17-making},

year  = {2017},

date = {2017-12-02},

urldate = {2017-12-02},

address = {Lübeck},

howpublished = {Session auf dem Barcamp Lübeck},

keywords = {BarCamp, BarCamp Lübeck (#bchl), fablab, laser cutting, leisure, maker faire, makerspace, making},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2017oerdeOERexp,

title = {OER für (freiberufliche) Trainer*innen: In 5 Schritten zum OER-Fachexperten},

author = {Anja Lorenz},

url = {http://bit.ly/oerde17-oerexp

https://open-educational-resources.de/oer-fuer-freiberufliche-trainerinnen-5-schritten-zum-oer-fachexperten/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N1SyBq1MXCs},

year  = {2017},

date = {2017-11-29},

urldate = {2017-11-29},

address = {Berlin},

abstract = {Dass OER für freiberufliche Trainerinnen und Trainer kein Selbstläufer ist, scheint offensichtlich: Ein direkter Gewinn ist zunächst nicht zu erwarten, wenn sie ihre Lernmaterialien unter einer freien Lizenz veröffentlichen und teilen. Im Weiterbildungsprogramm zum OER-Fachexperten macht der BDVT zusammen mit der FH Lübeck auf das Thema in dieser Zielgruppe aufmerksam und motiviert dazu, OER pädagogisch nutzenstiftend einzusetzen. Mehr Informationen dazu unter www.oer-fachexperten.de},

howpublished = {Soloauftritt und Lightningtalk auf dem OER-Fachforum 2017},

keywords = {eLearning, lightning talk, massive open online course (MOOC), mooin, OER-Fachexperten (OERexp), OERde, OERde17, open educational ressources (OER)},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2017oerdeMOOCs,

title = {Make-a-MOOC auf mooin},

author = {Anja Lorenz and Oliver Tacke},

url = {http://bit.ly/oerde17-mooinmaker

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ylu_vY-yaqA},

year  = {2017},

date = {2017-11-28},

urldate = {2017-11-28},

address = {Berlin},

abstract = {Die FH Lübeck nutzt ihre MOOC-Plattform mooin seit 2015, um eigene offene Online-Kurse bereitzustellen. Seit Mitte 2016 wurde diese Möglichkeit auch zunehmend für externe MOOC-Maker geöffnet: Jede*r kann selbst Kurse erstellen und anbieten – und das kostenlos, solange es sich um MOOCs handelt, die für alle offen stehen. Neben einer kurzen Einführung ins „Onboarding“ bei mooin stellen wir Ergebnisse einer Befragung der externen MOOC-Maker vor.},

howpublished = {Soloauftritt auf dem OER-Fachforum 2017},

keywords = {collaboration, eLearning, lightning talk, massive open online course (MOOC), mooin, open educational ressources (OER)},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2017metanook,

title = {Freies Lernen im Internet: wie an der Fachhochschule Lübeck offene Online-Kurse erstellt werden},

author = {Anja Lorenz and Oliver Tacke},

url = {https://2017.nook-luebeck.de/2017/talk/mooin

http://bit.ly/metanook-mooin

https://youtu.be/QwXTAvWiNEQ},

year  = {2017},

date = {2017-11-10},

urldate = {2017-10-06},

address = {Lübeck},

organization = {MetaMeute & Chaotikum e.V.},

abstract = {25 Jahre Deutsche Einheit, Netzwerksicherheit, Senioren im Ehrenamt, Windenergietechnik, Deutsche Aussprache für syrische Deutschlerner*innen, Roboter in der Bildung... alle diese Kurse sind auf der lübecker Plattform https://mooin.oncampus.de/ zu Hause – und noch viele mehr. Sie sind für jede*n frei zugängig und viele sind mit einer freien Lizenz versehen (Stichwort OER). Die Kurse wurden überwiegend vom Institut für Lerndienstleistungen der Fachhochschule Lübeck produziert, mittlerweile haben wir die Plattform aber auch für andere Anbieter von Kursen geöffnet.



Im Vortrag stellen wir Euch die Plattform und ihre Kurse vor und plaudern ein wenig aus dem Nähkästchen: Welche Fragen stellen Ü60-Nutzer? Funktionieren Badges denn überhaupt? Wie kaputt ist die Plattform, wenn man sie auch mit arabischer Sprache bereitstellen möchte? ... und wer bezahlt unser Gehalt, wenn alles kostenlos ist?},

howpublished = {Vortrag auf der MetaNOOK 2017 (MetaMeite engages the awesome Night of Knowledge)},

keywords = {digitalisation, eLearning, higher education, massive open online course (MOOC), mooin, open educational ressources (OER)},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{vfh17-lorenz,

title = {Making},

author = {Anja Lorenz},

url = {http://bit.ly/vhf17-making},

year  = {2017},

date = {2017-06-16},

urldate = {2017-06-16},

address = {Lübeck},

institution = {Virtuelle Fachhochschule},

howpublished = {Vortrag auf dem VFH-Symposium 2017},

keywords = {fablab, laser cutting, maker faire, makerspace, making},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2017obn,

title = {Moin mooin: Bildung für alle dank Internet!},

author = {Anja Lorenz},

url = {http://bit.ly/obnMOOIN-intro},

year  = {2017},

date = {2017-05-04},

urldate = {2017-05-04},

address = {Lübeck},

school = {Virtuelle Fachhochschule},

howpublished = {Webinar für das Studienmodul "Mediendidaktik und -Konzeption" (Dozentin: Ilona Buchem)},

keywords = {digital badges, massive open online course (MOOC), mooin},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{seipel2017oerexp,

title = {OER-Fachexperten braucht die Welt....},

author = {Hedwig Seipel and Sabine Preusse and Anja Lorenz and Markus Deimann},

url = {https://www.oer-fachexperten.de/oer-fachexperten-braucht-die-welt/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=reL_08O2oS8

https://connect.oncampus.de/p6sl22nvxd8/

https://h5p.org/node/64521},

year  = {2017},

date = {2017-03-30},

urldate = {2017-04-26},

address = {online},

organization = {Projekt OER-MuMiW},

howpublished = {Webinar im Rahmen der Open Education Week 2017},

keywords = {BDVT, digitalisation, massive open online course (MOOC), mooin, open educational ressources (OER), train the trainer},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2017oersax,

title = {Bildungspolitik trifft OER-Community – und begreift(?)},

author = {Anja Lorenz},

url = {https://secret-cow-level.de/wordpress/2017/03/deja-vu-oer-in-sachsen-oersax/

http://bit.ly/oersax-lorenz

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yYBNFcy2v-k

http://blogs.hrz.tu-freiberg.de/oersax/ready-steady-go-kick-off-oersax-am-17-03/

http://blogs.hrz.tu-freiberg.de/oersax/keynote-vortrag-von-anja-lorenz-online/},

year  = {2017},

date = {2017-03-17},

urldate = {2017-03-17},

address = {Dresden},

organization = {OERsax},

school = {Technische Universität Dresden, Bergakademie Freiberg und HTW Dresden},

howpublished = {Keynote auf dem Kick-Off des Projekts OERsax},

keywords = {coer16, keynote, L3T, OER-Award, OERde, OERde16, OERsax, open educational ressources (OER), SOOC, SOOPAL},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}

@misc{lorenz2016montagsbildung,

title = {LaserCutten im Fablab},

author = {Anja Lorenz},

url = {https://secret-cow-level.de/wordpress/2016/12/ich-und-mein-holz-lasercutten-im-fablab/

http://bit.ly/ocmb-fablab

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lglgA1SnmkA},

year  = {2016},

date = {2016-12-12},

urldate = {2017-04-26},

address = {Lübeck},

institution = {Institut für Lerndienstleistungen & oncampus},

school = {Fachhochschule Lübeck},

howpublished = {Vortrag im Rahmen der Montagsbildung beim ILD},

keywords = {fablab, hackerspace, laser cutting, makerspace, making, montagsbildung},

pubstate = {published},

tppubtype = {presentation}

}